If there is a bomb threat against an aircraft, should the controller suggest actions for the pilot to take?

In the context of a bomb threat against an aircraft, the correct approach emphasizes the responsibility and authority of the pilot in making decisions regarding the safety of the flight. While air traffic controllers are trained to provide support and assistance during emergency situations, the final decision-making power rests with the pilot. This approach is critical for maintaining a clear chain of command and ensuring that the pilot can respond effectively to the situation based on their training and knowledge of the aircraft.

Controllers can certainly provide necessary information, such as situational awareness and updates on available resources, but suggesting specific actions could lead to confusion or complicate the pilot's response. The pilot has the training and expertise to assess the situation and determine the best course of action, including whether to divert, hold, or land.

Understanding the role of both the controller and the pilot during emergencies is paramount, and this choice aligns with established protocols that respect the autonomy and judgment of the flight crew while still maintaining clear communication and support from air traffic control.